thoughts
vs knowledge
Among
the disadvantages of a retirement, wondering into many new fields
of interest, those you were always attracted to but tired by your
professional work - and not having a basic knowledge of them -
should be high on the list. Let me give you an example.
When
thinking on the beginning of large scale farming in Near East and
Egypt, roughly 10 thousand years ago, I myself - before any
reading on the subject - tried to relate this colossal event in
human history to the climate change. The obvious
"suspect" was the end of last glacial period, popularly
known as the Ice Age, about 12.5 thousand years ago. Later, I
found that idea in several respectable books and was proud of
myself. |
Till
recently, that is, when I found out my reasoning being of the
mark. Namely, my reasoning went like this: if the permanent ice
was as south as Central Europe then Near East and North Africa
were temperate paradise, just calling for the plow and shovel. And
then I saw the map of the last glacial vegetation (see a detail of
the map below) showing that the areas of interest were either
semi-deserts or deserts. So much for logical thinking without
facts.
Now I know much more about huge floods after the last
glacial period (some five hundred of the world’s mythologies
include accounts of flood) and the role of regular flooding of the
big rivers, Tigris and Euphrates in Mesopotamia and Nil in Egypt,
ten thousand years ago as well as today. And I’m glad I didn’t
popularize my "temperate paradise" hypothesis. |