from
Darwin’s Dangerous Idea by Daniel C. Dennett (1995)
We
used to sing a lot when I was a child, around the campfire at
summer camp, at school and Sunday school, or gathered around the
piano at home. One of my favorite songs was "Tell Me
Why".
Tell
me why the stars do shine,
Tell
me why the ivy twines,
Tell
me why sky’s so blue,
Then
I will tell you just why I love you.
Because
God made the stars to shine,
Because
God made the ivy twine,
Because
God made the sky so blue,
Because
God made you, That’s why I love you.
The
sweet, simple vision of the song, taken literally, is one that
most of us have outgrown, however fondly we may recall it. The
kindly God who lovingly fashioned each and every one of us (all
creatures great and small) and sprinkled the sky with shining
stars for our delight - that God is, like Santa Claus, a myth of
childhood, not anything a sane, undeluded adult could literally
believe in. That God must either be turned into a symbol for
something less concrete or abandoned altogether.
There
is no future in a sacred myth. Why not? Because of our curiosity.
Because, as song reminds us, we want to know why. We may
have outgrown the song’s answer, but we will never outgrown the
question. Whatever we hold precious, we cannot protect it from our
curiosity, because being who we are, one of the things we deem
precious is the truth. Our love of truth is surely a central
element in the meaning we find in our lives.