SIR
2011 : Croatia & Europe (2)
I’m
still arguing with myself about Scimago Institutions Rankings
(SIR) World Report 2011, commented already a week ago. Is
Croatia (and Bulgaria, Serbia, Hungary ...) really so miserable as Normalized
Impact (NI) score presents? What objections can I make?
Well,
NI score is of rather limited scope and purpose - it measures one
scientific institution’s impact within the world scientific
community only. It does not measure the impact of that
institution to the national economy, culture or the quality of life
in general. Then, from that angle, maybe Croatian share of the world
scientific impact is not so miserable. The upper chart on the right
relate summarized country NIs to its population and gross domestic
product at purchasing power parity. As one would expect, one million
Swiss people have much larger scientific impact than one million
Croats and, that really hurts, Croats are poor enough to make their
impact cheaper. An ‘advantage’ for being underdeveloped in an
integrated world.
And
look (lower chart on the right), science education in the
underdeveloped countries like Croatia and Slovakia, as seen by the PISA
(Programme for International Student Assessment), a world- wide
evaluation of 15-year-old school pupils' scholastic performance,
does not correlate with the country’s scientific achievements.
Then, what, a good science education for what? International Science
Olympics of boys and girls?
Get
real, I’m warning myself, take a close look. Croatian Academy
of Sciences and Arts (CASA) didn’t make it at all among 3,042
institutions that together are responsible for more than 80% of
worldwide scientific output. It’s probably not CASA but CARA
(Croatian Association of Retired Academicians). Moreover, Institute
Ruđer
Bošković
(IRB), the largest Croatian scientific
institution by far, is probably underscored (NI of 0.8) because SIR
didn’t recognize the impact of IRB’s high energy physicists -
one of them is the leading Croatian proponent of Opus Day.
The farfetched Black Energy is the God’s energy, right? |
 |