|
Organic
label. Nowadays US agricultural policy,
like the Declaration of Independence, is founded on the principle that all
carrots are created equal, even though there’s good reason to believe
this isn’t really true. But in an agricultural system dedicated to
quantity rather then quality, the fiction that all foods are created equal
is essential. This is why, in inaugurating the federal organic program in
2000, the secretary of agriculture went out of his way to say that organic
food is no better than conventional food. "The organic label is a
marketing tool", Secretary Glickman said. "It is not a statement
about food safety. Nor is ‘organic’ a value judgment about nutrition
or quality."
Some
intriguing recent research suggests otherwise. A study by University of
California-Davis researches published in the Journal of Agriculture and
Food Chemistry in 2003 described an experiment in which identical
varieties of corn, strawberries,
and blackberries
grown in neighboring plots using different methods (including
organically and conventionally) were compared for level of vitamins
and polyphenols. Polyphenols are a group of secondary metabolites
manufactured by plants that we’ve recently learned play an
important role in human health and nutrition. Many are potent
antioxidants, some play a role in preventing or fighting cancer;
others exhibit anti- microbial properties. The Davis researchers
found that organic and otherwise sustainably grown fruits and
vegetables contained significantly higher levels of both ascorbic
acid (vitamin C) and a wide range of polyphenols.
The
recent discovery of these secondary metabolites in plants has
brought our understanding of the biological and chemical complexity
of foods to a deeper level of refinement; history suggests we haven’t
gotten anywhere near the bottom of this question, either. The first
level was reached early in the nineteenth century with the
identification of the macronutri- ents - protein, carbohydrate, and
fat. Having isolated these compounds, chemists thought they’d
unlocked the key to human nutrition. Yet some people (such as
sailors) living on diets rich in macronutrients nevertheless got
sick. The mystery was solved when scientists discovered the major
vitamins - a second key to human nutrition. Now it’s the
polyphenols in plants that we’re learning play a critical role in
keeping us healthy. (And which might explain why diets heavy in
processed food fortified with vitamins still aren’t as nutritious
as fresh foods.) You wonder what else is going on these plants, what
other undiscovered qualities in them we’ve evolved to depend on.
Michael
Pollan: The omnivore's dilemma, A natural history of four meals,
Penguin Books, New York, 2006.
|
|
|
|
|
|